The Best Burgers & Sandwiches on Hilton Head Island
Every burgers & sandwiches pick below earned its spot — tasted by locals, never sponsored.
BestBites Fave
Fried Grouper Sandwich
Hinchey's Chicago Bar & Grill · Coligny & South End · $
You get a whole lotta feesh with this one
BestBites Fave
Reuben Sandwich
Hinchey's Chicago Bar & Grill · Coligny & South End · $
Who doesn't love a Reuben sandy?
BestBites Fave
Buffalo Triggerfish Sandwich
Captain Woody’s · Coligny & South End · $$
Triggerfish is hugely underrated, as is this sandy
BestBites Fave
Grilled Chicken Melt
Lagerhead Tavern · North End · $$
Comfort food at its finest
BestBites Fave
Carolina Crunch Burger
Lagerhead Tavern · North End · $$
Where did this burger come from?
BestBites Fave
BBQ Chicken Wrap
Street Meet American Tavern · North End · $
One of the tastiest sandwiches on the island
Fan Pick
The Hot Chic
Stu's Surfside Subs & Suds · Coligny & South End · $
This toasted sandwich is loaded with tasty chicky
Fan Pick
Bronx Bomber
Gruby's New York Deli · Mid-Island · $$
Large sandy with outstanding flavor
BestBites Fave
Spicy Chicken N’ Pickles
Nectar · Mid-Island · $
A southern classic sure to impress
BestBites Fave
Santa Fe Chicken Panini
Gr8 Bites · North End · $
Tender chicken panini with great flavor
BestBites Fave
Shrimp Nola Po' Boy
Poseidon Coastal Cuisine · Shelter Cove · $
A tasty locally caught shrimp po' boy, can't go wrong
Fan Pick
Fat Boy Sub
Stu's Surfside Subs & Suds · Coligny & South End · $
A meaty sandwich for a hearty appetite
BestBites Fave
Philly Cheesesteak
Gringo’s · Coligny & South End · $
Outstanding Philly if you’re not from Philly, of course
BestBites Fave
The Jedi
Stu's Surfside Subs & Suds · Coligny & South End · $
A worthy Italian sandy
BestBites Fave
Original Weggie
Giuseppi's Pizza & Pasta House · Shelter Cove · $
Unique and tasty sandy
BestBites Fave
Matt's Special
Gruby's New York Deli · Mid-Island · $
The sandwich for someone who doesn't need one the size of their head
BestBites Fave
The Arthur Avenue Special
Gruby's New York Deli · Mid-Island · $$
This is a sandwich fit for a large appetite
BestBites Fave
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Local Legend Brewing Company · Coligny & South End · $$
Gotta love a great Nashville hot chicken sandy
BestBites Fave
1/2 Pound Burger
Harold’s Diner · Mid-Island · $
Best burger value on the island
BestBites Fave
Saloon Burger
Sundown Saloon · North End · $
Half pound angus burger is a local secret
BestBites Fave
Double Burger
Tin & Tallow · North End · $
One of the best smash burgers on the island
BestBites Fave
Shrimp & Lobster Grilled Cheese
The Salty Dog · Sea Pines · $$
This sandwich is incredibly flavorful and a go-to option
BestBites Fave
BBQ Burger
Captain Woody’s · Coligny & South End · $
One of the best hamburgers on the island
BestBites Fave
Burnt End Sliders
The Smokehouse · Coligny & South End · $
Great BBQ can come in small sizes
BestBites Fave
#17 - The Islander
Stu's Surfside Subs & Suds · Coligny & South End · $
Best sandwich on HHI