The Best Seafood on Hilton Head Island

Every seafood pick below earned its spot — tasted by locals, never sponsored.

Fried Grouper Sandwich at Hinchey's Chicago Bar & Grill BestBites Fave

Fried Grouper Sandwich

Hinchey's Chicago Bar & Grill · Coligny & South End · $

You get a whole lotta feesh with this one
Buffalo Triggerfish Sandwich at Captain Woody’s BestBites Fave

Buffalo Triggerfish Sandwich

Captain Woody’s · Coligny & South End · $$

Triggerfish is hugely underrated, as is this sandy
Shrimp Chili at Captain Woody’s BestBites Fave

Shrimp Chili

Captain Woody’s · Coligny & South End · $

Chili never tasted so good
Super Grouper at Mixx on Main BestBites Fave

Super Grouper

Mixx on Main · North End · $$

An island favorite seafood dish for a reason
Calamari at Mixx on Main BestBites Fave

Calamari

Mixx on Main · North End · $

Tasty, gently battered app
Shrimp Nola Po' Boy at Poseidon Coastal Cuisine BestBites Fave

Shrimp Nola Po' Boy

Poseidon Coastal Cuisine · Shelter Cove · $

A tasty locally caught shrimp po' boy, can't go wrong
Shrimp & Risotto at Fish Camp on Broad Creek BestBites Fave

Shrimp & Risotto

Fish Camp on Broad Creek · Mid-Island · $$$

A smorgasbord of tasty seafood awaits
Oysters at The Old Oyster Factory BestBites Fave

Oysters

The Old Oyster Factory · Mid-Island · $$

The place has oyster in the name, it has to be good
Lobster Tacos at The Black Marlin Bayside Grill BestBites Fave

Lobster Tacos

The Black Marlin Bayside Grill · Mid-Island · $$

Makes your mouth water just thinking about them
Fried Flounder Seafood Basket at Up the Creek BestBites Fave

Fried Flounder Seafood Basket

Up the Creek · Mid-Island · $$

Psst, it’s fish & chips with an awkward name
Lowcountry Crab Dip at The Salty Dog BestBites Fave

Lowcountry Crab Dip

The Salty Dog · Sea Pines · $

A tasty lunch opener
New Orleans Jambalaya at Skull Creek Boathouse BestBites Fave

New Orleans Jambalaya

Skull Creek Boathouse · North End · $$$

This is jambalaya for the jambalaya lovers out there
Oysters at Hudson's BestBites Fave

Oysters

Hudson's · North End · $

Arguably the best oysters on the island
Lowcountry Gumbo at Crazy Crab Jarvis Creek BestBites Fave

Lowcountry Gumbo

Crazy Crab Jarvis Creek · North End · $

A classic lowcountry gumbo with an uncommon spice
Shrimp & Lobster Grilled Cheese at The Salty Dog BestBites Fave

Shrimp & Lobster Grilled Cheese

The Salty Dog · Sea Pines · $$

This sandwich is incredibly flavorful and a go-to option
Bacon Wrapped BBQ Shrimp at Crazy Crab Jarvis Creek BestBites Fave

Bacon Wrapped BBQ Shrimp

Crazy Crab Jarvis Creek · North End · $$

It’s insane how delicious this meal is
Parmesan Crusted Grouper at The SandBar BestBites Fave

Parmesan Crusted Grouper

The SandBar · Coligny & South End · $$

Jack's favorite seafood dish on HHI
New England Clam Chowder at Hudson's BestBites Fave

New England Clam Chowder

Hudson's · North End · $

Hard to top this clam chowder
Shrimp & Polenta at Fish Camp on Broad Creek BestBites Fave

Shrimp & Polenta

Fish Camp on Broad Creek · Mid-Island · $$

Delicious shrimp dish celebrates a little spice and more

← Browse every bite