Hawaiian Pizza at New York City Pizza
BestBites Fave

Hawaiian Pizza

New York City Pizza · North End · $$ · Pizza & Italian

Our own find — and we’d order it again.

Andy is a pizza guy, so we try to check out as many pizza options as possible. We finally stopped by the New York City Pizza on the north end of the island for the first time. We went with the NY style option, though they have several to choose from. Hawaiian is one of our faves, so it was a good place to start. The big takeaway is that you get a ton of toppings. Every inch was covered by a pineapple or a piece of ham. It was super cheesy, but lighter on the sauce. This option was a little soggy due to all the pineapple, we assume. But the crust was very good. Definitely a place we would come back to, particularly since it’s close to our home. Not the best pizza on the island, but a worthy option and one we would order again.