What to Order at Nosh NY Bagels

Mid-Island · 2 bites we recommend — tasted in person, never sponsored.

Michael and Jen Penchansky moved south and couldn’t find a bagel worth eating, so they made their own — first in Okatie, then here. Nosh is Yiddish for eating with enthusiasm. The Wexford shop is small and built for takeout, with a pickup window.